- a rejection of postmodern culture's confusion about anthropology and gender, and an embrace of traditional and Biblical norms for masculinity (i.e., strength with gentleness, justice with mercy, wisdom and humility, basic courtesy, boldness to face down evil and to lead to the good, protection of others, especially those who can't protect themselves, the Biblical "widows and orphans" - in a word, chivalry),
- chastity,
- fidelity for fathers and husbands (and a deliberate promotion of the necessary norms for being good fathers and husbands, over against the self-indulgent decadence of the culture and the scourge of divorce),
- return to the Mass and the sacrament of Confession,
- prayer and personal devotion.
Information, resources, and community building for all the members of the Deacon Community of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Sioux City. Thoughts, Catholic commentary, and occasional homilies from Deacon David.
Wednesday, September 30, 2015
Bishop Olmstead (Phoenix) - "Into the Breach"
Yesterday, Bishop Olmstead published an apostolic exhortation to men to step "into the breach" of faith and spiritual life. His exhortation is excellent! Please read it. It's entirely relevant to deacons and those of you in deacon formation, too. The main point is about a revival of Catholic manliness by:
Thursday, September 24, 2015
Pope Francis in America - Homily, Midday Prayer with the Bishops, 9/23
This is, I think, the clearest, most comprehensive articulation that I've seen, of what Pope Francis is trying to do as Pope. Some of his actions and words have, at times, been seen with confusion and ambiguity. His "style" can be abrupt and imprecise, especially in comparison with his two immediate predecessors. But here, there is nothing unclear or objectionable in what he's laying out, and there is a full embrace of Tradition, just as I also embrace, believe, and strive to act. Especially, his words here are full of charity and joy, as he invites his brother bishops (and, through them, all of us) again to work with him in the vineyard of Christ. Read the whole thing at the above link.
Some highlights:
The heart of the Pope expands to include everyone. To testify to the immensity of God’s love is the heart of the mission entrusted to the Successor of Peter, the Vicar of the One who on the cross embraced the whole of mankind. May no member of Christ’s Body and the American people feel excluded from the Pope’s embrace. Wherever the name of Jesus is spoken, may the Pope’s voice also be heard to affirm that: “He is the Savior”! From your great coastal cities to the plains of the Midwest, from the deep South to the far reaches of the West, wherever your people gather in the Eucharistic assembly, may the Pope be not simply a name but a felt presence, sustaining the fervent plea of the Bride: “Come, Lord!” Whenever a hand reaches out to do good or to show the love of Christ, to dry a tear or bring comfort to the lonely, to show the way to one who is lost or to console a broken heart, to help the fallen or to teach those thirsting for truth, to forgive or to offer a new start in God… know that the Pope is at your side, the Pope supports you. He puts his hand on your own, a hand wrinkled with age, but by God’s grace still able to support and encourage.
Some highlights:
![]() |
| www.gettyimages.com |
I speak to you as the Bishop of Rome, called by God in old age, and from a land which is also American, to watch over the unity of the universal Church and to encourage in charity the journey of all the particular Churches toward ever greater knowledge, faith and love of Christ. Reading over your names, looking at your faces, knowing the extent of your churchmanship and conscious of the devotion which you have always shown for the Successor of Peter, I must tell you that I do not feel a stranger in your midst. I am a native of a land which is also vast, with great open ranges, a land which, like your own, received the faith from itinerant missionaries. I too know how hard it is to sow the Gospel among people from different worlds, with hearts often hardened by the trials of a lengthy journey. Nor am I unaware of the efforts made over the years to build up the Church amid the prairies, mountains, cities and suburbs of a frequently inhospitable land, where frontiers are always provisional and easy answers do not always work. What does work is the combination of the epic struggle of the pioneers and the homely wisdom and endurance of the settlers. As one of your poets has put it, “strong and tireless wings” combined with the wisdom of one who “knows the mountains”.
![]() |
| www.gettyimages.com |
We are bishops of the Church, shepherds appointed by God to feed his flock. Our greatest joy is to be shepherds, and only shepherds, pastors with undivided hearts and selfless devotion. We need to preserve this joy and never let ourselves be robbed of it. The evil one roars like a lion, anxious to devour it, wearing us down in our resolve to be all that we are called to be, not for ourselves but in gift and service to the “Shepherd of our souls” (1 Pet 2:25). The heart of our identity is to be sought in constant prayer, in preaching (Acts 6:4) and in shepherding the flock entrusted to our care (Jn 21:15-17; Acts 20:28-31). Ours must not be just any kind of prayer, but familiar union with Christ, in which we daily encounter his gaze and sense that he is asking us the question: “Who is my mother? Who are my brothers?” (Mk 3:31-34). One in which we can calmly reply: “Lord, here is your mother, here are your brothers! I hand them over to you; they are the ones whom you entrusted to me”. Such trusting union with Christ is what nourishes the life of a pastor.
The great mission which the Lord gives us is one which we carry out in communion, collegially. The world is already so torn and divided, brokenness is now everywhere. Consequently, the Church, “the seamless garment of the Lord” cannot allow herself to be rent, broken or fought over. Our mission as bishops is first and foremost to solidify unity, a unity whose content is defined by the Word of God and the one Bread of Heaven. With these two realities each of the Churches entrusted to us remains Catholic, because open to, and in communion with, all the particular Churches and with the Church of Rome which “presides in charity”. It is imperative, therefore, to watch over that unity, to safeguard it, to promote it and to bear witness to it as a sign and instrument which, beyond every barrier, unites nations, races, classes and generations.
Labels:
Catholic identity,
Catholic joy,
charity,
Pope Francis,
Tradition
Thursday, July 30, 2015
Is the "deaconess" a female deacon?
Deacon Greg Kandra on Deacon's Bench notes today a recently-published interview with Austrian theologian Dietmar Winkler of Salzburg University. The English version is picked up by the Tablet, hardly a reliable source, and my German isn't up to reading the original. Dr. Winkler is reported to have said, among other things,
“Married priests and women deacons should be reintroduced as soon as possible. That would bring new dynamism to the Church”, the future dean of Salzburg University’s Catholic theological faculty, Professor Dietmar Winkler, told the Austrian daily Salzburger Nachrichten…
What Dr. Winkler and so many who promote the ordination of women to the diaconate don't know (or at least don't seem to know) is that the ancient order of "deaconess" was never seen by the Latin Church as a female version of the Order of Deacons. Rather, it was parallel to the Lector - a ministry, certainly, but not a consecrated ministry of the sort reserved to the sacrament of Holy Orders. Deaconesses did not ever receive that sacrament. Deaconesses had several roles, nearly all of which were serving other women in situations where it would be improper or scandalous for men to do so. The most common role was in the baptism of women, which was often done disrobed; from that also came a catechetical roles forming those women. Other liturgical roles, like reading and ushering, were predominantly in women's monastic houses or groups, where men (apart from priests) were not present.
This distinction is deeply embedded in the liturgical texts of the "ordination" of deaconesses. (One can, in the broad sense, speak of "ordination" of a deaconess. The root meaning of "ordination" is simply "induction into an order," and no one is arguing that deaconesses did not constitute an order, like that of the Order of Widows, say. But this should never be confused with the special sense of "ordination" which means "induction into one of the orders of the sacrament of Holy Orders.") Even if the symbols of the diaconate (laying on of hands, giving of a stole) could be used for deaconesses sometimes, the words (and therefore the meaning) of the rituals remain quite different. For example, here's the earliest known pair of ritual texts, from the Apostolic Constitutions from Syria in the 4th century (Book III has other interesting info on deacons and deaconesses):
Prayer for a deacon: "...[H]ear our prayer, Lord, and give ear to our supplication, and let your face shine on this your servant who is appointed to you for ministry, and fill him with spirit and power, as you filled Stephen the protomartyr and imitator of the sufferings of your Christ. And grant that he, acceptably performing the sacred ministry entrusted to him, may be worthy of a higher rank through the mediation of your Christ..."*
Prayer for a deaconess: "Eternal Father..., creator of man and woman, who filled with the Spirit Miriam and Deborah and Anna and Huldah; who did not disdain that your only-begotten Son should be born of a woman; who also in the tent of the testimony and in the temple appointed women to be guardians of your holy gates: now look upon this your servant who is being appointed for your ministry, and give her the Holy Spirit and cleanse her from every defilement of body and spirit so that she may worthily complete the work committed to her, to your glory and the praise of your Christ..."*
Note the key distinctions. The ministry of the deacon is "sacred," it is done "with spirit and power," and it may lead to "a higher rank" (namely the priesthood). The ministry of the deaconess is simply "ministry," not sacred (Holy Orders) ministry, it is done with the spirit but not "power," and it is completed worthily without any indication of "higher rank." The text for a lector from the same source uses, for a lector, the same "ministry" (not sacred ministry) and the same "spirit" (not spirit and powe), but then does indicate the "higher rank" that follows.
One might also note that the Old Testament typology and the New Testament roots of the deaconess are likewise completely different from those of deacons, as elaborated in other version of the rituals. So there's really no question that deaconesses are not female versions of the Holy Orders rank of deacon, but rather female versions of something like the lector, with a few differences specific to their unique context (lectors don't baptize, for example, except in case of emergency, but they do catechize). Finally, one might point out that, in fact, we have already "restored" the deaconess in the modern Church - they're now called "Lay Ecclesial Ministers."
*(Source: Paul Bradshaw, Ordination Rites of the Ancient Churches of East and West (New York, 1990) 116-7.)
“Married priests and women deacons should be reintroduced as soon as possible. That would bring new dynamism to the Church”, the future dean of Salzburg University’s Catholic theological faculty, Professor Dietmar Winkler, told the Austrian daily Salzburger Nachrichten…
What Dr. Winkler and so many who promote the ordination of women to the diaconate don't know (or at least don't seem to know) is that the ancient order of "deaconess" was never seen by the Latin Church as a female version of the Order of Deacons. Rather, it was parallel to the Lector - a ministry, certainly, but not a consecrated ministry of the sort reserved to the sacrament of Holy Orders. Deaconesses did not ever receive that sacrament. Deaconesses had several roles, nearly all of which were serving other women in situations where it would be improper or scandalous for men to do so. The most common role was in the baptism of women, which was often done disrobed; from that also came a catechetical roles forming those women. Other liturgical roles, like reading and ushering, were predominantly in women's monastic houses or groups, where men (apart from priests) were not present.
This distinction is deeply embedded in the liturgical texts of the "ordination" of deaconesses. (One can, in the broad sense, speak of "ordination" of a deaconess. The root meaning of "ordination" is simply "induction into an order," and no one is arguing that deaconesses did not constitute an order, like that of the Order of Widows, say. But this should never be confused with the special sense of "ordination" which means "induction into one of the orders of the sacrament of Holy Orders.") Even if the symbols of the diaconate (laying on of hands, giving of a stole) could be used for deaconesses sometimes, the words (and therefore the meaning) of the rituals remain quite different. For example, here's the earliest known pair of ritual texts, from the Apostolic Constitutions from Syria in the 4th century (Book III has other interesting info on deacons and deaconesses):
Prayer for a deacon: "...[H]ear our prayer, Lord, and give ear to our supplication, and let your face shine on this your servant who is appointed to you for ministry, and fill him with spirit and power, as you filled Stephen the protomartyr and imitator of the sufferings of your Christ. And grant that he, acceptably performing the sacred ministry entrusted to him, may be worthy of a higher rank through the mediation of your Christ..."*
Prayer for a deaconess: "Eternal Father..., creator of man and woman, who filled with the Spirit Miriam and Deborah and Anna and Huldah; who did not disdain that your only-begotten Son should be born of a woman; who also in the tent of the testimony and in the temple appointed women to be guardians of your holy gates: now look upon this your servant who is being appointed for your ministry, and give her the Holy Spirit and cleanse her from every defilement of body and spirit so that she may worthily complete the work committed to her, to your glory and the praise of your Christ..."*
Note the key distinctions. The ministry of the deacon is "sacred," it is done "with spirit and power," and it may lead to "a higher rank" (namely the priesthood). The ministry of the deaconess is simply "ministry," not sacred (Holy Orders) ministry, it is done with the spirit but not "power," and it is completed worthily without any indication of "higher rank." The text for a lector from the same source uses, for a lector, the same "ministry" (not sacred ministry) and the same "spirit" (not spirit and powe), but then does indicate the "higher rank" that follows.
One might also note that the Old Testament typology and the New Testament roots of the deaconess are likewise completely different from those of deacons, as elaborated in other version of the rituals. So there's really no question that deaconesses are not female versions of the Holy Orders rank of deacon, but rather female versions of something like the lector, with a few differences specific to their unique context (lectors don't baptize, for example, except in case of emergency, but they do catechize). Finally, one might point out that, in fact, we have already "restored" the deaconess in the modern Church - they're now called "Lay Ecclesial Ministers."
*(Source: Paul Bradshaw, Ordination Rites of the Ancient Churches of East and West (New York, 1990) 116-7.)
Wednesday, July 8, 2015
Homily outline for Wednesday 7/8/15 - Evangelization
Here's today's Gospel (Mt 10:1-7):
Jesus summoned his Twelve disciples
and gave them authority over unclean spirits to drive them out
and to cure every disease and every illness.
The names of the Twelve Apostles are these:
first, Simon called Peter, and his brother Andrew;
James, the son of Zebedee, and his brother John;
Philip and Bartholomew,
Thomas and Matthew the tax collector;
James, the son of Alphaeus, and Thaddeus;
Simon the Cananean, and Judas Iscariot
who betrayed Jesus.
Jesus sent out these Twelve after instructing them thus,
“Do not go into pagan territory or enter a Samaritan town.
Go rather to the lost sheep of the house of Israel.
As you go, make this proclamation: ‘The Kingdom of heaven is at hand.’”
For my homily, I gave St. Jerome's two-point interpretation of this passage from the Catena Aurea. Here's the quick summary.
First point - Scripture doesn't contradict itself. So, this sending of the Apostles only to their fellow Jews is not in contradiction with the later sending to "all nations" (Mt 28:19). Rather, it's two steps in the fulfillment of God's one plan for salvation. The Jews already had their special status as God's preistly people, and the Revelation of Scripture, to prepare them for this proclamation of the Kingdom; and indeed, many of them did hear and respond, not least the Apostles themselves. The Gentiles, lacking this relationship with God, would wait for the Resurrection to have the whole Gospel proclaimed to them.
Second point flows from this. Since Scripture doesn't contradict itself, we can't read this passage as any kind of limit on where and when we ourselves proclaim the Kingdom. We're sent everyone by our Baptism and Confirmation, and for the ordained, by our Orders. But, St. Jerome says, the verse should be read spiritually, as an indication of how we proclaim. If we live our lives in the manner of those who don't know Christ ("Gentiles"), or who have accepted only part of the Gospel ("Samaritans"), we can't evangelize effectively. We have to live entirely as disciples of Christ, and evangelize from that standpoint first and foremost, by how we live. Thus we may show in our daily actions, even before we may have a chance to speak, the joy, mercy, grace, and hope of Jesus Christ, to a world starving for His love.
![]() |
| https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Apostles_capp.JPG |
and gave them authority over unclean spirits to drive them out
and to cure every disease and every illness.
The names of the Twelve Apostles are these:
first, Simon called Peter, and his brother Andrew;
James, the son of Zebedee, and his brother John;
Philip and Bartholomew,
Thomas and Matthew the tax collector;
James, the son of Alphaeus, and Thaddeus;
Simon the Cananean, and Judas Iscariot
who betrayed Jesus.
Jesus sent out these Twelve after instructing them thus,
“Do not go into pagan territory or enter a Samaritan town.
Go rather to the lost sheep of the house of Israel.
As you go, make this proclamation: ‘The Kingdom of heaven is at hand.’”
For my homily, I gave St. Jerome's two-point interpretation of this passage from the Catena Aurea. Here's the quick summary.
First point - Scripture doesn't contradict itself. So, this sending of the Apostles only to their fellow Jews is not in contradiction with the later sending to "all nations" (Mt 28:19). Rather, it's two steps in the fulfillment of God's one plan for salvation. The Jews already had their special status as God's preistly people, and the Revelation of Scripture, to prepare them for this proclamation of the Kingdom; and indeed, many of them did hear and respond, not least the Apostles themselves. The Gentiles, lacking this relationship with God, would wait for the Resurrection to have the whole Gospel proclaimed to them.
Second point flows from this. Since Scripture doesn't contradict itself, we can't read this passage as any kind of limit on where and when we ourselves proclaim the Kingdom. We're sent everyone by our Baptism and Confirmation, and for the ordained, by our Orders. But, St. Jerome says, the verse should be read spiritually, as an indication of how we proclaim. If we live our lives in the manner of those who don't know Christ ("Gentiles"), or who have accepted only part of the Gospel ("Samaritans"), we can't evangelize effectively. We have to live entirely as disciples of Christ, and evangelize from that standpoint first and foremost, by how we live. Thus we may show in our daily actions, even before we may have a chance to speak, the joy, mercy, grace, and hope of Jesus Christ, to a world starving for His love.
Monday, May 4, 2015
Order of Penitents
Dominican Father Thomas Michelet has written an intriguing article in Nova et Vetera, (English
translation) arguing that a reclaiming of something like the ancient Order of Penitents could be pastorally useful today. For those who find themselves in irregular situations with respect to the sacramental disciplines of the Church, such as the divorced-and-civilly-remarried or those who have fallen away from the Church, it could provide both a concrete position in the Church, instead of the often-nebulous injunction not to present oneself for Communion; and a predictable structure for offering them pastoral care and a path of conversion and regularization. What he has sketched out in the article appears to remain consistent with Scripture and Tradition, and the current discipline of the Sacraments, while attempting a bridge between where people are (away from the Sacraments) and returning them to full communion. Notably, Fr. Michelet argues for the importance of reaching out to those most in need of penance, in order to bring them to an interior understanding of their sins and need for conversion, rather than (as we too often do) just waiting for them to show up, contrite.
| Christ the Good Shepherd( from St. John's Icon Studio) |
Labels:
Confession,
Order of Penitents,
Synod on the Family
Friday, January 30, 2015
Cardinal Rodriguez Maradiaga, "Church of Mercy of Pope Francis," response in several parts - Part Four (and last)
This continues my explication and response to Cardinal Rodriguez Maradiaga's essay and talk, "The Church of Mercy of Pope Francis." Previous parts are here and here and here.
“The Church of Mercy with Pope Francis” (cont'd)
“The Church of Mercy with Pope Francis” (cont'd)
3. To Bear Witness to
God’s Mercy is to Commit to Man
The best testimony of charity and mercy is found especially
in the saints, in their high level of Christian life and in the maturity of the
live idea of God [True; but, their witness is also
witness to “traditional” spirituality, and the apostolic and sacramental order
inherent in the Church. To invoke them
is to defend that “traditional” spirituality which he seems want to change, and
thus undermines his putative argument.]. The God loved and worshiped by
saints reveals Himself gradually along with the fidelity and contemplative
growth of the believer [“no one knows who the Son is except the Father, or who
the Father is except the Son and anyone to whom the Son chooses to reveal him.”
(Luke 10: 22)].
The biblical God is not the God of Theodicy or of pure
rationality [Not sure what he means by this. Does he mean this in a “traditional” way,
namely, that, while our reason applied to the created world can find evidence
that reveals God’s nature as Creator, reason alone cannot know God without the
gift of faith? Or does he mean something
else, such as that “traditional” theology (often disparagingly called
“onto-theology” should be rejected as “triumphalist” and “domesticating” of
God?]: it is a God that has to be found, that has to be received as a
gift and as a revelation. It is a different God… The Christian God is not
exactly the God of the philosophers, of the logic and of the Theists. [Augustine and Aquinas, e.g., would certainly agree with
this.] Just believing in God does
not make you a Christian. [“Faith without works is
dead.”] A Christian is someone
who has discovered the biblical God; the God of Abraham, of Moses, of the
Prophets, that revealed Himself in plenitude in the God of Jesus. [I assume he does not mean to imply, by the parallelism (God
of Abraham = God of Moses = God of Jesus), that Jesus is not God.] Through the history of Salvation,
there is a gradual revelation of the face of the true and only God [i.e., Jesus Christ, true God and true man, who gave us the
Church and the Sacraments as the primary means of salvation, and sends thereby
the Holy Spirit to unite us to Himself and the Father]. The way of the
Church’s pastoral conversion today is to guide individuals and cultures through
that gradual revelation, though in different contexts and experiences. [This is a false dichotomy, if meant in contradistinction to
some “traditional” method of pastoral conversion, imagined not to introduce to others that same face of God in Jesus Christ
through appropriate contexts and experiences.]
Nothing reveals God more than love. Therefore, Pope Francis says
(speech of November 14, 2013) that, “The Church’s primary task is to bear
witness to the mercy of God and to encourage generous reactions of solidarity
in order to open a future of hope. For where hope increases, energy and
commitment to building a more human and just social order also grows, and new
possibilities for sustainable and healthy development emerge.”
3.1 Full-Time
Christians
In the Family Synod (October 2014) something notable
happened for the first time: [What he describes here is
exactly what Pope Benedict described having happened at Vatican II (e.g.,
again, the 2005 Christmas address, and elsewhere). So this dichotomy of “two synods” is hardly
the “first time.” Is he ignorant or
forgetful of Pope Benedict’s remarks, or is he implicitly contradicting and
rejecting them?] There were like
two Synods because outside the precinct where the Synod Fathers were gathered,
there was a media Synod that denoted a perverse intention to confuse opinions,
invent answers, imagine solutions and exaggerate positions of those of us
gathered there; instead, inside the working room a charismatic, serene,
cordial, filled-with-unction-and-faith synod was taking place, seeking to agree
and to answer the essential issues of family and marriage.
Many [in the false, media synod] identified
as the unique and fundamental topic, issues that were merely secondary. For
example, we did not talk only about giving “communion” to re-married Christians
—that was a collateral argument, it was never essential. What was really said,
and I repeat and emphasize, is that the realities of dissolved and rebuilt
families are not an impediment to live and participate in the abundant life of
the Church; that the “sacramental communion” is not the only way to vitally
participate in the pastoral dynamic of the parish community and that every
Christian couple that seeks God will find Him because he allows Himself to be
found and that every re-married Christian can be a full-time Christian, has a
right to be happy, and his house can become also a place where the love of God
is born witness. [Well, yes, but... this should not be
taken in a sense which downplays the uniqueness of the Eucharist. There are many reasons why one might refrain
from approaching Holy Communion at any given time, and such experiences indeed
do not prevent the love of God from indwelling in us; but at the same time, it
remains true that participation in the Holy Eucharist is the “source and
summit,” and therefore the ideal, of the Christian life, toward which we are
meant to strive. If it lies within our
power to remove an obstacle to our reception of Holy Communion, and we refuse
to do so, are we not rejecting thereby the fullness of God’s love for us? We must not take a complacent or minimalist
attitude about our total union with Christ.]
For me, there is no “place in the basement” of the Church
for Catholics that have wanted to rebuild their lives having remarried, though
they cannot receive the Sacrament of Communion; there is no corner in attic for
migrants that do not have documents in order and want to prepare their children
in the sacraments of Christian Initiation; there is no special window in Heaven
to assist those who have left the Catholic Church and have gone to other places
seeking the warmth, refuge and respect that their mother has not been able to
provide. [I think this is basically correct (Mt 23:4,
Col 3:13, Eph 4:2).]
All these are challenges to our conscience and a strong and
tough demand to our parish practices that are so rigid and narrow-minded. [Indeed, it is possible that we fail to live up to these high
standards of radical love, and that we fail to evangelize and to foster faith
in others. And some of the ways in which
we can so fail might well be called “rigid” or “narrow-minded.” However, if he means here to identify “rigid
and narrow-minded” with “traditionalist,” as above, then he’s going too far.] That
is why the Pope said to be careful not to turn the parish and episcopal offices
into “customs.” And he is completely right. (Santa Marta, May 25, 2013). To
remember the whole message, I quote: “We are many times ‘controllers of faith,’
instead of becoming ‘facilitators’ of the faith of the people,” lamented the
Pope during his daily mass at Santa Marta’s Guest House in the Vatican. In his
homily that was broadcasted by Vatican Radio, the Argentine Pope mentioned a
priest who refused to baptize the son of a single mother, “this girl who had
the courage to carry her pregnancy (…) and what does she find? A closed door,”
affirmed the Pope. [We need to know more about this
anecdote before we can conclude that this priest acted “rigidly” or
“narrow-mindedly.” Just by itself, the
quote does not demonstrate what he claims.]
Nobody is excluded from the Church of Christ. [True, but many people exclude themselves by rejecting God’s
mercy, love, and grace.] There is
a place for everybody, for the migrants, for those who one day abandoned the
Church but come back convinced that they can stay forever, for those
married-divorced-remarried, for the poor, for everybody. Within these
categories fall those that Francis calls “the least”, when he encourages: “The
Church must step outside herself. To go where? To the outskirts of existence,
whatever they may be. If we step outside ourselves we find poverty. We cannot
put up with this! We cannot become starched Christians, those over-educated
Christians who speak of theological matters as they calmly sip their tea. [Another false dichotomy.
Although his exhortation to embrace the mission is sound, the
contrasting of “education” with “courage” is belied by, say, St. Dominic,
etc.] No! We must become
courageous Christians and go in search of the people who are the very flesh of
Christ, those who are the flesh of Christ! (Vigil of Pentecost, May 18, 2013).
3.2 The Culture of
Good
The Pope’s words sounded strong when he said, “Be men and
women with others and for others: true champions at the service of others”
(December 2, 2013). [Another “traditional”
exhortation.] Following this, the
Holy Father tells us something fundamental, three points that I want to share
with you today to finish my talk here: [First point:
importance of public Christian witness to mercy, love, hope] “In your
society, which is deeply marked by secularization, I encourage you also to be
present in the public debate, in all the areas where man is at issue, to make
God’s mercy and his tenderness for every creature visible.” Yes, dear Friends,
let it be a task and commitment for you to work courageously and heroically
“where man is at issue.” Only in that manner will we bear witness of God’s
mercy, the mercy that is love —and love that begins at home. [His three points here returns to the tenor of Part I, above,
which seems quite orthodox, but now there is a deep, ambiguous tension in his
words. Does he mean this conclusion in a
“traditional” way, with the apostolic and sacramental commitments thus implied,
or is he evoking some “new” ecclesial vision and order?]
[Second point: importance of strong
spiritual foundations] The incarnate aspect of spirituality, turning
life into a transcendental humanism according to the Spirit, is what lays the
foundation for the Christian mystic. [Are we to take
this in continuity or in rupture with the great spiritual
masters?] It is focused on the
search for God through Jesus, but also focused on man and the search for
fraternal love. It lives in the hope that the Kingdom will have no end but it
centers completely on the tasks of a Kingdom in history and in society. It
receives faith as a gift from God, irrepressible to any human experience, but
it knows that faith takes diverse shapes [“unity in
diversity” has always been acceptable; but there are limits, since some diversities do indeed break the
unity] and demands according to the cultures, the challenges of society
and the individual commitment, and that all human or Christian commitment must
also be a place of the experience of God.
[Third point: priority of the
“preferential option for the poor”] Since certainly, the privileged
“place” in which Christ’s Mercy becomes incarnate and becomes practice is in
the love for the brothers and sisters, and in the preferential love for the
poor and the suffering. The temporal reality that summarizes all the
incarnations of the mystic, all the realism of the Christian spirit, and that
gathers all the demands of the practice of the faith and love, is the brother,
is the poor. [Are we meant to take this in continuity
with the “traditional” understanding of the Great Commandment, or as a “new”
understanding? How does this
understanding of love of neighbor relate to the traditional understanding of
the love of God?] The God hiding
in the faces of our brothers is the supreme experience of incarnation and to
practice mercy is its definitive stamp because “mercy is the true force that
can save man and the world” (September 15, 2013). [Again,
continuity or rupture?]
[Overall, this essay is pretty
forceful and coherent, but it has a significant issue in the middle. Part I and the first two sections of Part 2
are clear and reasonable. He does not
directly contradict anything in the Church’s traditional understanding of
Scripture, Tradition, mission, vocation, or evangelization. However, one must supply the full
understanding of these topics. The absence
of any mention of the place of the Sacraments becomes striking in the middle of
the essay. In this sense, in the last
two sections of Part 2 (2.3 and 2.4), when dealing explicitly with the
“traditional” Church and the changes following Vatican II, he seems strongly to
take the position of the “hermeneutic of rupture,” rejected by Pope Benedict
XVI (and Pope St. John Paul II). His
language is vague and his meanings remain rather uncertain. It is difficult to understand what he could
mean if his vision is not essentially that of the hermeneutic of rupture, but
it is also difficult to know clearly what he means even within that point of
view. His arguments in this section
remain unconvincing, especially the flawed argument from authority. In the final section of the essay (Part 3),
his failure to mention the sacramental economy as the primary avenue of mercy
for the Church and the world in the beginning of the essay, along with the
appearance of taking the hermeneutic-of-rupture position in the middle of the
essay, introduces a devastating ambiguity into his conclusions. The reader no longer knows how to understand
what is being put forth. The language
and content seem to hew close to the Church’s proper understanding of the
topics at issue, but we cannot be certain that he means the same things by
these same words.
The best reading of the essay, then,
I would suggest, is to set aside the unconvincing middle section, and to
embrace the hermeneutic of continuity at least implicitly taken in the beginning. By this reading, the conclusion becomes a
straightforward, fairly strong and urgent, exhortation to deepen our missionary
zeal, and to work more to overcome the various obstacles to the spread of the
Gospel that our own weakness, sins, and particular historical/cultural blind
spots might impose.]
Thursday, January 29, 2015
Cardinal Rodriguez Maradiaga, "Church of Mercy of Pope Francis," response in several parts - Part Three
This continues my explication and response to Cardinal Rodriguez Maradiaga's essay and talk, "The Church of Mercy of Pope Francis." Previous parts are here and here.
“The Church of Mercy with Pope Francis” (cont'd)
“The Church of Mercy with Pope Francis” (cont'd)
2.3. The Finish
Point: The Church of Mercy
We walk as Church towards a deep and global renovation. [I think “renewal” is what he means.] For this renovation to be sincerely
Catholic, it must encompass all of the historical dimensions of the Church.
Specifically, there is no true ecclesial renovation without
a transformation of the institutions [Here he begins to
say things that seem to contradict what he has already established. Especially, it’s not at all clear what it
might mean to “transform” the essential institutions of the Church – namely,
the hierarchical-apostolic order, the organization into dioceses/parishes/religious
houses, and all that serves the sacramental and pastoral care of souls – in any
sense that would remain “Catholic.”]; of the quality and focus of the
activities; of the mystic and the spiritual. Usually, renovation begins with
pastoral activities. For it is there where the inconsistencies of a certain
“model” of the Church and reality are primarily experienced. The missionaries,
the evangelists on the “margins” of the Church, are the first ones to notice
the insufficiency of the “traditional” ways of action; the pastoral criticism
begins with the experience of the mission in the “peripheries.” Changes and
adjustments begin there. [This, too, is curious,
because the “margins” of the Church (Asia, Africa, the pro-life movement, the
pro-traditional-liturgy movement, etc.) seem quite consistently to want
something much different than this next paragraph calls for:]
After Vatican Council II, the methods and content of
evangelization and Christian education change [not
always for the better]. The liturgy changes: local languages are adopted,
some rituals and symbols change, measurements are taken for a greater
participation, etc. The missionary perspective changes: the missionary must
know the culture, the human situation; the missionary must establish an
evangelizing dialogue with those realities. “Social action” changes, it is no
longer just charity and development services but also struggle for justice,
human rights and liberation… [Some notable false
dichotomies in here. One thinks, e.g., of the first generation of Jesuit
missionaries in Asia in the 16th century, of whom it certainly could
not be said that they did not learn and value the culture, the language, the
people, etc.; nor is “the struggle for justice, human rights, and liberation” a
new thing in the Church in the later 20th century. But since these efforts have always been
there, too, this paragraph implies either a repudiation of the Church before
Vatican II, or a confusion about what the Church did for its mission in
previous generations. In either case, it
is quite superficial and misleading to present it in this manner.]
For Christian coherency, certain institutional and
organizational changes are contemplated simultaneously: new functions require
new suitable institutions. [Again, it’s not at all
clear what “new functions” he means.]
The Council propelled institutional renovations, following
the logic of the Spirit. [Note the dangerous
implication that the Church before the Council was not following the same
logic.] These reforms encompass
all levels of the ecclesial organization: the religious congregations or
missionary societies —whose “Chapters of Renovation” multiply— the diocesan and
Vatican Curia, Episcopal Conferences, the Synods, the parishes, the pastoral
areas, the presbyteries, the lay apostolic institutions, the teaching of
theology, the seminaries, the catholic schools… New institutions for missionary
dialogue emerge: ecumenism, Jews, other religions… Everything in the Church
changes consistent with a renewed pastoral model. [Exaggeration
for effect? Clearly, not everything in the Church changes. But it’s important to note, I think, what
he’s eliding here by implication, namely, the apostolic and sacramental order
labelled “Tradition.” This therefore could be taken to contradict what he
sketched out in Part I, above.]
Maybe some thought that the Church renovation was only that.
But the institutional and functional changes —alone in themselves— proved
insufficient, superficial. [This language becomes quite
dangerous. Note how he now implicitly
pits “the Church before the Council” and “the Church after the Council” against
each other, in just the manner Pope Benedict taught must not be done (e.g., in
the 2005 Christmas address to the Curia).] Sometimes they created new
problems and crises both unnecessary and deep. Any change in the Church
eventually requires considering a renovation of the motivations that the new
options inspire. Without deep-rooted, living and explicit motivations, no human
group, no institution and no society can survive for a long time, much less
renovate itself. Motivations answer to the fundamental “why” of the options,
the enterprises, the demands, and the same reason for being of the institution.
The Pope wants to take this Church renovation to the point
where it becomes irreversible. The wind that propels the sails of the Church
towards the open sea of its deep and total renovation is Mercy.
For the Church, the motivations are more than essential;
they are its identity stamp. The “why” of its organization and its action
cannot be decisively explained by the human sciences or the pure historical
rationality: they refer to Jesus and his Gospel as the global, indispensable
and predominant motivation. It is the motivation of the Spirit. Therefore, to
speak of motivations in Christianity is to speak of the mystical, of
spirituality. [Right.
In Part I, he seemed to agree that it is of the essence of the Church
founded by Christ that this “why” goes to the reception of grace/mercy and the
journey of conversion, via Scripture and Tradition, the Sacraments, and the
works of mercy. Now, he’s hinting at some new “why,” some new relationship in
the Church between “mercy” and “concrete love,” that would change the essential
shape of Tradition.]
The institutional and functional renovation of the Church
requires a renovation of its mystical dimension. And at the roots of the
mystical is mercy.
2.4 The Maternal
Heart of Mercy
Catholic spirituality in history, due to its same incarnate
nature, never takes place as an “activity” isolated from the pastoral, the
theological, the social and the cultural conditions. [That’s
certainly true of the Sacraments, too.] Since
one of its dimensions —it is not the only one— is to motivate believers to
follow of Jesus. This following acquires renovated nuances, demands and topics
consistent with the mission and with the human experience of the believers.
While the life of Christ and the Gospels are always the same, the experiences
and the options that inspire are always historical. [What
does this mean for Tradition?]
Spirituality is not a science nor one more praxis in the
Church. It is the “nourishment” of the pastoral, the theology and the
community, whatever their “model” is. [But in this
broad sense, “spirituality” must be unchanging,
part of what comes to the Church immediately
from God. He seemed to accept this in
Part I, but now he seems to contradict himself.]
When this was forgotten by the process of ecclesial
renovation, [I’m guessing he missed the implication
here that it was not forgotten by the
Church before the Council...] this
caused “schizophrenia” in some Christians, which is one of the causes of many
failures. In a short time, they progressed in all of the levels of the
renovation. They changed many pastoral, theological, and disciplinary categories.
The image and the mission of the Church changed. Likewise, its concept that
related faith with history and society changed; therefore the social and
political options became more important.
In this context, there was no mystical renovation and it
remained “traditional,” consistent with another vision of the faith and of the
mission, and inconsistent with the new ecclesial experiences. [And there it is: “traditional” = “bad.” Notice how he now elides Tradition by
labeling it merely “another vision of the faith the mission” – as if the
fundamental orientation of the Church were so malleable! Again, in his argument in Part I, he seemed
to accept Tradition; now, he is claiming that “traditional” spirituality,
rooted in the “traditional” understanding of Scriptures, apostolicity,
sacramentality, devotions, etc., is no longer fit for the Church. So, either this section of the essay is
confused and unhelpful, or else his real argument is this: If our fundamental
spiritual “experience” and “vision” remains that of the Apostles, the Fathers,
and the Councils, then we are “schizophrenic” and “inconsistent!”]
In this context, a spirituality does not motivate, it
becomes irrelevant. It ends up being perceived as a useless appendix and ends
up being abandoned, since a mystic that does not nourish the human experience
stops having meaning; a spirituality that is foreign to the ecclesial model
that is being lived leads to the crisis of the Christian “schizophrenia.” Many
abandonments of the ecclesial life, and even of the faith, are rooted there. [Even granting this “being foreign to the ecclesial model” to
be true (which I don’t), this does not follow:] The only answer is not
in abandoning all mystic or reversing the renovation of the institutions or
options (due to fear of a collapse of the Christian values), but in deeply
renovating the faith and spirituality starting from love to reach mercy. [Assuming he really means what he says here, this is an
extraordinarily sweeping claim. He’s saying that the “traditional” model of the
Church, and the spirituality that underpins it, do not “start from love to
reach mercy.” So the whole of Church history, all the works of all the great
saints and mystics of the past, the whole sacramental order and experience of
the Church for 19 centuries, that was not really what God intended for the
Church. But now, somehow, almost ex nihilo, suddenly this tiny handful of
people understand everything better and clearer than all the doctors of the
Church and the whole of the faithful...] That is what the Pope wants. [And just in case you’re not convinced, he pulls out the
argument from authority. The (current)
Pope is claimed to want it, so it must be right.]
In that regard, on July 28, 2013, Pope Francis said
(speech): “She gives birth, suckles, gives growth, corrects, nourishes and
leads by the hand… So we need a church capable of rediscovering the maternal
womb of mercy. Without mercy we have little chance nowadays of becoming part of
a world of ‘wounded’ persons in need of understanding, forgiveness and love.” [This quote doesn’t support what he claims. Since “the Church is always in need of
renewal,” the Pope is quite correct (in that sense) to say this; but such “rediscovery”
means a return to what the Church has always done, in evangelical and apostolic
integrity, not a substitution of some new ecclesial vision for the “traditional”
one.]
On December 9, 2014, at the Chapel of the Santa Marta Guest
House I heard the Pope say loud and clear what I will share now: “I ask myself,
what is the consolation of the Church? [2 Cor 1:3-5 -
he paraphrases thus:] Just as an
individual is consoled when he feels the mercy and forgiveness of the Lord, the
Church rejoices and is happy when she goes out of herself [offering the same mercy and forgiveness to those who long,
even inchoately, for reconciliation with God; as said above, this ultimately
leads to full sacramental participation.]. In the Gospel, the pastor who
goes out goes to seek the lost sheep – he could keep accounts like a good
businessman. [He could say]: ‘Ninety-nine sheep, if I lose one, it’s no
problem; the balance sheet – gains and losses. But it’s fine, we can get by.’ No,
he has the heart of a shepherd, he goes out and searches for [the lost sheep]
until he finds it, and then he rejoices, he is joyful.”
“When the Church does not do this [Has
there ever been a time or place when the Church, qua Church, has not done this?
Or does he mean, when the members of the Church don’t?], then the
Church stops herself, is closed in on herself, even if she is well organized,
has a perfect organizational chart, everything’s fine, everything’s tidy – but
she lacks joy, she lacks peace, and so she becomes a disheartened Church,
anxious, sad, a Church that seems more like a spinster than a mother, and this
Church doesn’t work, it is a Church in a museum. The joy of the Church is to
give birth [i.e., to new disciples]; the joy of
the Church is to go out of herself to give life [i.e.,
by those new disciples’ sacramental participation and sharing in the mission];
the joy of the Church is to go out to seek the sheep that are lost; the joy of
the Church is precisely the tenderness of the shepherd, the tenderness of the
mother.”
“May the Lord give us the grace of working, of being joyful
Christians in the fruitfulness of Mother Church, and keep us from falling into
the attitude of these sad Christians, impatient, disheartened, anxious, that have
all the perfection in the Church, but do not have ‘children.’ [This is good. As
disciples, any of us might experience discouragement and loss of zeal, and we
need this prayer continually.] May
the Lord console us with the consolation of a Mother Church that goes out of
herself and consoles us with the consolation of the tenderness of Jesus and His
mercy in the forgiveness of our sins.” [Again, these
words of Pope Francis do not support the supposed argument about Tradition the
Cardinal is possibly trying to make. The Pope is saying that we’re not good
enough disciples, that we’re distracted by all kinds of weakness and sin from
carrying out the mission of the Church consistently. That’s true and always has been, and yet God
works through us in spite of it. This is
quite a “traditional” thing to say. But
it doesn’t follow from this that “traditional” spirituality is faulty or
inadequate.]
These are words accompanied by gestures of the Pope that
speak of coherence. His actions and his harmony with those who need consolation
are small pieces of encyclicals, they are itinerant “Pope Magisterium,” [Argument from authority again. Moreover, if Pope Francis’s “gestures” and
“small pieces of encyclicals” constitute this “itinerant papal Magisterium,”
then so, logically, did those of Pope Benedict XVI, Pope St. John Paul II, and
all the popes... which obviously leads to conflicting claims and irreconcilable
differences within the Magisterium. So
this becomes a reductio ad absurdum,
and is clearly not tenable. See LG #22, 25; Heb 13:9; Mt 7:15; etc.] they
are prophetic gestures that arouse admiration and cause the holy emulation of
what he does, because he does it as Christ did and Peter summarizes it at
Cornelius’ house: “He went about doing good” (Acts 10: 38).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


